Video Assistant Referee (VAR) has been a contentious topic in English football ever since its introduction during the 2019-20 season. The Premier League was the last of Europe’s major leagues to adopt VAR, and its implementation has been far from smooth. There has been a lack of consensus on what exactly VAR should be, resulting in a hybrid model that has left many dissatisfied. Wolverhampton Wanderers recently made headlines by becoming the first club to call for VAR to be scrapped ahead of the upcoming season.
Wolves’ resolution to scrap VAR will be voted on during the Premier League clubs’ annual general meeting in Harrogate on June 6. While it is unlikely to garner the necessary 14 votes to pass, the motion presents an opportunity for reflection and potentially a reset. Clubs that compete regularly in European competitions are not expected to support the proposal, as they have invested significantly in the VAR system, including the upcoming semi-automated offside technology.
Wolves’ negative experience with VAR is well-documented, with the club having a net score of minus-17 in decisions over the past five seasons. This frustration culminated in their call for VAR to be scrapped, citing numerous instances of contentious decisions that have affected their matches. From errors logged by the Independent Key Match Incidents Panel to disagreements with on-field decisions, Wolves have been vocal about their dissatisfaction with the system.
While VAR has improved decision accuracy statistically, fans continue to express discontent with the system. The lack of progress in enhancing the supporter experience since VAR’s introduction seven years ago highlights a need for reform. The Premier League’s reluctance to embrace changes that could enhance the overall fan experience has resulted in a stalemate in the integration of VAR.
To rebuild trust in VAR, the Premier League must reevaluate its approach to the system. Referees need to have more control and authority in making crucial decisions, including making greater use of the pitchside monitor. By allowing referees to take a more active role in VAR decisions, the Premier League can restore faith in the system and address concerns raised by clubs like Wolves.
Wolves’ proposal signals a growing sentiment among clubs and fans for a more transparent and consistent application of VAR in English football. By aligning VAR protocols with those of other leagues and reemphasizing the “clear and obvious” standard, the Premier League can overcome some of the challenges associated with VAR and improve its acceptance among stakeholders.
The debate surrounding VAR in English football is far from over. While Wolves’ proposal may not lead to immediate change, it underscores the need for continued discussion and potential reforms to the VAR system. By addressing the concerns raised by clubs, players, and fans, the Premier League can work towards a more effective and widely accepted VAR implementation that enhances the overall quality of the game.